OTL's player disconnection issue

Posted
Gaming Overload Overload Teams League
The Overload Teams League has started off fairly well. We've played 26 games in the first month, completed a small one-day tournament, and have had five teams play each other at least once. But there's one issue that's come up that's been really tough to call. There was a player disconnection issue that recently came up where a player BSOD'd and there was some confusion on what to do. I wanted to put something in writing before this happens again.

First, some background.

In Descent 3, Heat aside, all servers were private. Players could come and go as they pleased, and you could always rejoin a game after crashing out. Game parameters were also much more open. Kill goals and time goals were text entries, not selections from a menu.

Revival confusingly bucked this trend in Overload, removing server browsers and opting for monolithic servers that can run multiple games at once. However, the only way to access these games is if you have the password AND you join before the game starts. There's no way to see what games are running, and even if you had the password you can't join a game in progress.

The Descent 3 Teams League pretty much ignored any issues with disconnections. DCs could simply be met with a substitution (subs were common in D3TL matches!), or by playing shorthanded until the disconnected player returned. Only a full server crash would suspend a match (in the D3TL Tournament, this only happend once ever, but was in the semifinals!), but players would pretty much just restart from the prior score and amount of time left with little fuss.

Disconnections in the OTL cause bigger problems.

  • Players can't reconnect to a game in progress, leaving their team short-handed.
  • If you wish to suspend the match, you have limited options to select time parameters in game.
  • Because of the above, disconnections can be seen as gaming the system, depending on many factors.

In short, in Overload, we as a league have to deal with a situation that's less than ideal. We are aware of the fact that games online are not nearly as flexible as they were with Descent 3, and we have to adjust as a result.

In the OMG/PTMC Terminal match, PuDLeZ BSOD'd and disconnected with approximately 2:30 remaining in the match while his team led by 5. Teams immediately stopped playing and agreed on starting a new game from the current score and time remaining (they had suggested 5 minutes, until I stepped in and asked for 3 to more match the time remaining). The stats from both games were combined for the final match score.

From my standpoint, that was awesome. Both teams came together to finish out the match despite the circumstances. And, this is the kind of model I want to encourage... work out a solution that both teams can agree on. However, teams will have different ideas on how to do this, so I think it's good to have a set of guidelines available along with what to do should teams NOT agree on a way to go forward. Here's what I came up with:

Should a player disconnect or a game end prematurely due to a crash or network outage, every effort should be made to get the current stats from the game up to that point in the match. Teams should then agree on what to do next, within the following guidelines:

- Teams can agree to restart a Challenge if 10 minutes or more remained on the clock at the time of the issue, or if multiple issues happen within a single match.
- Teams can agree to end a game with the score as is if less than 3 minutes remained on the clock at the time of the issue.
- Teams can agree to play a 2nd game, combining the scores of both games for the final score of a single match. The second game's time limit should be as close to one of the time options available in game as possible to the amount of time remaining when the issue occurred. For instance, if there was 6:23 on the clock, teams could agree to play the 2nd game with either a 5 minute or 7 minute time limit.

In all cases where a match is suspended and resumed, the same pilots must fly for both teams, as substitutions are not normally supported in Overload games.

If teams cannot agree on what to do, an administrator can be asked to decide how to proceed, and they will make the decision. The administrator may also opt to adjudicate the match accordingly in extreme cases.

If one player is repeatedly having these kind of issues, they may be suspended from the league until their issues are resolved. If it is deemed that the player is acting maliciously, they may be banned from the league.

I don't want it to feel like I'm ignoring the momentum argument, so I'll address it here. Momentum is a very real thing, and it sucks to have it taken away by an extraordinary circumstance. However, examples of leagues or competitions that put extra time on the clock because of such an issue is exceedingly rare. In fact, more often than not, you end up LOSING time. Here are some examples of what other leagues do, where, surprisingly, many take place in the sport's biggest games of the year.


I'm sure there are plenty more examples to put forth, but overwhelmingly the concept of momentum is not given much thought in any of these cases. Either they drop the rest of the game, pick up where they left off later, or they start over. Nowhere is something arbitrary like 5 extra minutes given just to facilitate a possible comeback or to restore momentum. And I think this makes sense, especially in an environment like the OTL where we have individual stats and want them to mean something instead of having them skewed by stats where matches were far too short or too long.

In an extraordinary circumstance, you need to make a judgement call that someone somewhere is not going to like. As long as we deal with these circumstances with consistency and with good intentions, that should be all anyone can ask of the league. I also strongly like giving teams options, and them letting them agree on which option to take, only calling in help when they can't agree.

Hopefully this will address the situation, but leave it open to discussion for now over on the OTL Discord. Apologies for not thinking of this sooner... I had a lot of situations planned out, and this was definitely not one of them!

Comments

Add Your Comments

roncli.com Blog
This is my blog where I give my thoughts and opinions on various topics and share my creative endeavors with the world. I run two personal blogs, but combine them here for ease of access.

Blogger - My oldest blog using the Blogger platform contains posts full of opinions, gaming, and code.

Tumblr - Tumblr posts are all about my creative side, containing music, videos, writings, and updates on my web creations.

You can select a category below to view the latest post, or browse thorugh the posts using the navigation found at the top and bottom of each post.
Categories
Coding (167)
Life (138)
Gaming (118)
Music (64)
World of Warcraft (48)
roncli.com (42)
Software (36)
Servers (29)
Hurricane Rita (27)
Six Minutes To Release (27)
Screenshot (25)
Hurricane Ike (24)
Projects (24)
Silliness (21)
Trax in Space (21)
Cent (19)
Crystal Space (15)
OSMusic.Net (14)
Blog (13)
Editorials (13)
LibWowArmory (13)
Lyrics (13)
roncli Productions (12)
VB.NET (12)
Descent (11)
LibWowAPI (10)
Descent 3 (9)
Due Process (9)
Backup (8)
CTG Music (8)
Node (8)
Overload Teams League (8)
Six Gaming Podcast (8)
ASP.Net (7)
Azure (7)
Buffalo (7)
League of Legends (7)
NWS (7)
Rendr (7)
SETI@Home (7)
The Nightstalker (7)
Video (7)
Diablo III (6)
Hard Drives (6)
Logs (6)
Overload (6)
Windows (6)
BOINC (5)
Cent Credits (5)
Cent Main Theme (5)
D3DSN (5)
Descent: Underground (5)
FreeBSD (5)
Google Desktop (5)
Google Earth (5)
Outpost Music (5)
Ron's Bronze Plays (5)
Sports (5)
UPS (5)
Birthday (4)
Buffalo Sabres (4)
Constellation (4)
Everytime (4)
JavaScript (4)
Preview (4)
Pwned Print (4)
roncli's Dumbass Award (4)
San Antonio (4)
Sigh of Excitement (4)
Six Gaming (4)
Steam (4)
Stripped Down (4)
The Observatory (4)
trac (4)
Twitch (4)
Visual Studio (4)
Winamp (4)
AJAX (3)
All In My Head (3)
Blackjack (3)
Chess (3)
Crypt of the NecroDancer (3)
D3TL (3)
DCL (3)
Gate (3)
Given Up (3)
Guitar (3)
Inspiration Edit (3)
jQuery Default Button (3)
MAME (3)
MediaTagConverter (3)
ModPlug (3)
NeonXSZ (3)
NetHack (3)
Numbers (3)
Paper (3)
PHP (3)
Rawr (3)
Sift (3)
SQL Server (3)
Tumblr (3)
Vision (3)
Year in Review (3)
AM Browser (2)
Asana (2)
ASP.Net RSS Toolkit (2)
Bicycle (2)
BlizzCon (2)
Cheevos FTW! (2)
Crazy Browser (2)
Descent Champions Ladder (2)
DMTB (2)
Docker (2)
Elbow (2)
Eternally (2)
Evans Blue (2)
Fire In My Heart (2)
Games (2)
GitHub (2)
GTR (2)
Houston Astros (2)
How To Play (2)
Hurricane Katrina (2)
iPhone (2)
IRC (2)
IsItUp (2)
Las Vegas (2)
Legs (2)
LibBeImba (2)
Minnesota Wild (2)
Miss Driller (2)
Module Sixteen (2)
Monitor Resolution (2)
NeKo (2)
New Zepsi Industries (2)
Niagara Falls (2)
Novus Compo (2)
Pittsburgh Penguins (2)
Poker (2)
Pwned Cars (2)
Reinstall (2)
Remake (2)
Retro (2)
roncli Productions Intro (2)
San Francisco (2)
San Francisco Rush 2049 (2)
slammy (2)
Sleep (2)
Solar (2)
SoundCloud (2)
Stress (2)
Strings (2)
Tempurpedic (2)
The Editor (2)
TNS Raw (2)
TopCoder (2)
Troupe (2)
w.bloggar (2)
Wedding (2)
XAML (2)
You (2)
Zepsi (2)
#modarchive Story 2 (1)
#occupygregstreet (1)
Absolute C++ (1)
Achaea (1)
Acronyms (1)
AdAware SW (1)
Adobe Acrobat (1)
AdventureQuest (1)
Alaska (1)
allen one (1)
AMD Settings (1)
Analyze (1)
APIs (1)
app.config (1)
Art (1)
ASSP (1)
Audiosurf (1)
Aveyond (1)
Awakening (1)
Bellaire (1)
BitTorrent (1)
Black Ox II (1)
Blackberry (1)
Blender (1)
Blogger (1)
BOINC Synergy (1)
BoincView (1)
Boom Bitches! (1)
Browserify (1)
Bullseye (1)
Byline (1)
CAD-KAS PDF Reader 2.4 (1)
CAPTCHA (1)
CDBurnerXP Pro (1)
CherryOS (1)
ChessCli (1)
Chick-Fil-A (1)
Child Controls (1)
clones (1)
ColdFusion (1)
Come Back To Me (1)
Compo (1)
Constellation Main Theme (1)
Cooking Lili (1)
Core Decision (1)
Crystal (1)
Databinding (1)
DataGrid (1)
DataGridView (1)
Deadly Drums (1)
Decade (1)
Dell (1)
Demogorgon (1)
Descent Rangers (1)
Diabetes (1)
Diamond Problem (1)
Doge2048 (1)
Doom's Day (1)
Double Buffer (1)
Dr. Jeffrey Masters (1)
Drama (1)
Dreamweaver (1)
Dudley's Dungeon (1)
Einstein@Home (1)
Ellon in the Dark (1)
Elon Musk (1)
EveryDNS (1)
Evolution (1)
Eyes (1)
Fedora Core 6 (1)
FeedPage (1)
Fiddler (1)
FlowDocument (1)
Foobar 2000 (1)
Foxit Reader (1)
Galveston (1)
Geocore (1)
GMail (1)
Google Calendar (1)
Google Chrome (1)
Google Pages (1)
Google Wave (1)
Grid (1)
grl (1)
Grooveshark (1)
Grunt (1)
GTR2 (1)
Guitar Solo (1)
Hackers (1)
HCC (1)
Hearthstone (1)
Heroes of the Storm (1)
HomesickAlien (1)
Houston Aeros (1)
ICallbackEventHandler (1)
If Paige Wins (1)
IIS (1)
Inno (1)
Internet Explorer (1)
Interview (1)
iPad (1)
Iron Chouquette (1)
Irrlicht (1)
Jaded (1)
jQuery UI (1)
jQuery UI Scroll Menu (1)
JW Player (1)
Kado Kado (1)
Kaspersky (1)
KFOS Inner Space Radio (1)
Know What (1)
Kromaia (1)
Let It Ride (1)
Let's Encrypt (1)
Let's Play (1)
LibWowHeroes (1)
LifeCast (1)
LINQ to Entities (1)
Linux (1)
Liquid Wars (1)
ListView (1)
Loading (1)
Lukan Schwigtenberg (1)
Mac (1)
MadTracker (1)
Mastodon (1)
Melbourne (1)
Melt (1)
Message From Beyond (1)
Micro Center (1)
Mistakes (1)
Monitor (1)
Mouse (1)
Moving (1)
Mr. Driller (1)
MSDN (1)
NASCAR SimRacing (1)
Network (1)
New Year (1)
olmod (1)
On Fire Series (1)
Opalus Factory (1)
Open Labs (1)
Open Source (1)
Operation Payback (1)
Overwatch (1)
PearPC (1)
Phony (1)
Piano (1)
Pingle (1)
pogo.com (1)
PowerStrip (1)
Programming (1)
PSP (1)
PXO (1)
Quadra (1)
Radeon (1)
Radio Shack (1)
Rant (1)
RedHeat (1)
Reject (1)
Release (1)
Religion (1)
Rendr Template (1)
Renegade (1)
Retrovirus (1)
Revival Productions (1)
RFLXT (1)
RIP (1)
RockMelt (1)
Scott Hanselman (1)
Self-Destruct Sequence Podcast (1)
Showsan (1)
Silverlight (1)
Sitemap Generator (1)
Smoke (1)
Sol Contingency (1)
Sound Blaster Audigy (1)
Speedrun (1)
Spelling (1)
SQL Reporting Services (1)
SSL Certificates (1)
Stanley Jakubowitz (1)
Starbase Arcade (1)
Starcraft II (1)
Starting All Over (1)
Story (1)
Sublevel Zero (1)
Swiss (1)
Tetris (1)
Thanksgiving (1)
The Crossroads (1)
The Time Now (1)
The Wight to Remain (1)
Time and Date (1)
Toronto (1)
Torrent Keeper (1)
Total Bollocks (1)
Trans-Siberian Orchestra (1)
TraxSurf (1)
Trillian (1)
Twitter (1)
Typing (1)
Ultimate Boot CD (1)
UpdatePanel (1)
US Interactive (1)
Video Bob (1)
ViewState (1)
Vince Young (1)
Vincent Lau (1)
Vocals (1)
Voyage (1)
Voyager: Ascension (1)
Walter Savitch (1)
Warlords of Draenor (1)
Weather (1)
Web3 (1)
Westward (1)
What Do I Know (1)
WikiLeaks (1)
Windows Defender (1)
winLAME (1)
Winter Classic (1)
Word Field (1)
World Record (1)
Worst Things in the World (1)
WPF (1)
Xamarian (1)
XBox (1)
XM Radio (1)
XML Web Services (1)
Yahoo! Pipes (1)
Yes (1)
You Are Not Alone (1)
Share This Page
Social Media
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I guess you CAN'T do it with True Value. cnn.com/2024/10/14/business/tr

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Former 2 time world champion DogPlayingTetris becomes the first player to ever rollover the level counter in NES Tetris, performing what's known in the community as "Rebirth". Final score: 29,486,164, 4216 lines, level 347 (256 + 91)... all huge world records.

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Back row... Mother with screaming infant, 300 lb linebacker, and me. Or what's left of me.

Reply Boost Favorite
Solitha
@solitha @mastodon.social

🚨 James McGovern 🚨

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I'd also love a 6 hour layover overnight instead of taking the red eye I was going to take and be 7 hours later getting into Cleveland than I wanted, why do you ask?

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Why yes, I'd love to leave at 4:40 to get to the airport at 6:20 for an 8:20 flight that got delayed to 9:05 which is too late for my connection so now I'm on a 10:20 flight instead. Why do you ask?

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Twitch getting SOMETHING right for once...

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

You may just be a po'boy, but I love you. β™₯️

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I've never had as much fun on comms for a Tetris match as I did tonight with NinjaOfNinjas for the silver bracket semis and finals. What a show!

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Logan Paul didn't qual for silver unfortunately. πŸ™ƒ

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I'm not done! I'll be casting the later rounds of the silver bracket today at 6:30 PM Pacific at twitch.tv/classictetris3. Cya there!

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I'll be live casting qualifiers today for CTWC at twitch.tv/classictetris2 at 1 PM Pacific and twitch.tv/classictetris3 at 3:30 PM Pacific. This year's CTWC is the craziest yet so don't miss it!

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Public restrooms are funny.

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

The golden state, more like the blackened state. πŸ”₯

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Just a note to everyone out there who still believes 2020 hasn't ended that today is Unquinquaginember 21st, 2020.

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Burritos can be used for bribing if necessary. 🌯 :)

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

@shanselman Who at Microsoft do I have to bribe to fix ADO so that those of us on dark mode who copy/paste text from one task to another can do so without our friends on light mode seeing dark text on a dark background?

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I updated the blog post with a statement from Revival. While I'm not particularly happy with Revival's decision, I understand their motives. It's just a shame that it was someone from Interplay that had to go and do this. "By games for gamers" my ass.

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Damn, got another Tetris world record! This time in the arcade variant developed by Atari. 6,008,005 points, 5,386 lines, round 363. Be warned, it's nearly FIVE HOURS. twitch.tv/videos/2131759212

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I certainly didn't have "Overload but with web3 features" on my 2024 bingo card. WTF did Revival Productions just do?

roncli.com/blogger/39495275106

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

@solitha New rule: cat tax. For every pun you post or repost, you're now required to pay the tax of posting one cute cat video.

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Today was a special day. I scored 1,016,221 points in classic NES Tetris, the first time I broke the 999,999 maxout barrier.

With that maxout, I became the oldest person to get their first ever maxout at 46 years 319 days.

After I scored that, I learned that today would have been 7-time Tetris world champion Jonas Neubauer's 43rd birthday.

I am FILLED with incredible emotion tonight.

clips.twitch.tv/AverageImporta

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

"I'm Sorry, What?!" The biggest bailout in the history of Descent II! youtube.com/watch?v=GLlTk7wa59

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

β€œBART anime merch" are three words that I would not have expected to go together, but here we are. railgoods.com/bart/anime/

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Does anyone else sing the chorus to "Cherish" by Kool & The Gang to themselves whenever they play or watch streams of Balatro? Or is that just me?

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I'm fact that's what Lingo needs: a "phone" block. The clue is an incorrect autocorrected form of the answer. πŸ™ƒ

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

It's like my phone knows I've been playing Lingo. I typed in "exited" and my phone was all:

⬜️ EXCITED ------
β–ͺ️
β–ͺ️

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

@arborelia Bag-les.

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

A comparison of the classic Tetris and Descent communities. Not a post I write lightly, either.

roncli.com/blogger/37031578090

Reply Boost Favorite
martin
@luftlesen @mstdn.jp

Aptiz played #Pentis again. In the beginning you can see roncli asking in the chat for the right version. About an hour later, he broke the #PentisRankings record with 60K ! Congratulations roncli πŸ† πŸŽ‰
twitch.tv/videos/2052528360?sr

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Yeah, it's season 11. But the OTL Season 6 highlight reel is up, this time Fireball has taken the reins! Check out this video jam packed full of kills, deaths, silliness, and Sirius puns. youtube.com/watch?v=SXstLVjnaG

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Over on , someone retweeted sympathy for the people being laid off today...

...and then said that Amazon Games was hiring. You know, the one that just had layoffs in NOVEMBER.

Honestly? Tech sucks right now.

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Seriously. Why is it called Sagittarius, A Star? Clearly, it's Sagittarius, A Black Hole. Silly astronomers.

Reply Boost Favorite
Cultural Historian: Dr. RGST
@DrRGST @mastodon.social
Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

This eslint/stylistic breakup is going to give me a headache. Don't developers have something better to do than give other developers busywork?

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Bing is so bad. otl.gg is being blocked in their search results, and Bing webmaster tools are absolutely useless, not telling me why it's being blocked.

Does anyone know of some way to get a human to look at this and see what's wrong with it?

Reply Boost Favorite
Olivia W'
@WLivi @retro.pizza

it's not actually common for real hackers to use two keyboards at once; that's just a stereo type.

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

I got my wish. πŸ€’

Reply Boost Favorite
Ronald M. Clifford
@roncli @mastodon.social

Me and my wife, despite buying a house of nice size, always seem to get in each other's way, be it in the kitchen, on the stairs, it doesn't matter. She's all up in my two square feet.

I often joke that all I want for Christmas is my two square feet.

Reply Boost Favorite
Join roncli on Discord!
Join the roncli Gaming Discord server for discussion about gaming, development, and more!
roncli.com Media Player